When it comes to agricultural machinery, two brands that often come to mind are John Deere and New Holland. Both are well-known manufacturers with a long history in the industry, and they offer a wide range of products designed to meet the needs of farmers and other agricultural professionals.
While there are many similarities between these two brands, there are also important differences that can make a big impact on the productivity and profitability of a farm. In this article, we’ll take a closer look at John Deere vs New Holland and explore the key factors that farmers should consider when choosing between these two brands.
About the Brand: John Deere vs. New Holland
John Deere, founded in 1837, is an iconic and widely recognized brand. John Deere himself founded the corporation. I admire their customer-centric approach; their design strategy and upgrades will prove beneficial for users.
Consumer Reports has recognized John Deere as the most dependable brand of lawn tractors and ZTR mowers.
Below, I will outline some reasons why New Holland is an exceptional brand. Under Sperry’s leadership, New Holland began manufacturing lawn and garden tractors in the 1970s and eventually sold their product line to Ariens.
As Ford sold its controlling stake in Ford-New Holland agricultural machinery firm to FIAT, their Toros models were replaced by New Holland-branded models. New Holland manufactured lawn and garden tractors until 2009 when production was discontinued.
John Deere vs. New Holland Tractors
75 Hp tractors
The John Deere 5075e and New Holland Workmaster 75 are two 3-cylinder engines offering almost the same maximum horsepower at 74.8 for John Deere and 74 for New Holland, both available in 4×2.
The John Deere is available only with 4×2, although New Holland also offers a 4×4 drivetrain option on their Workmaster 75 model.
In conclusion, both tractors are excellent brands but you may find the New Holland to be more cost-effective and better equipped for handling North Georgia’s rugged terrain.
The 4X4 option makes all the difference when working in hill country conditions or wet conditions – even when carrying identical loads.
50 Hp tractors
When looking at 50 horsepower tractor options, John Deere 5055e and New Holland Workmaster 50 are two top contenders. The John Deere offers approximately two additional HP over the New Holland Workmaster 50.
John Deere 5055E offers 2WD, 4×4, and 4×4 differential options; New Holland Boomer 50 offers only 4×4. Furthermore, the New Holland is slightly shorter at 17,500mm overall length compared to John Deere’s 20,500 mm; this gives it more maneuverability around hobby farms or tighter spaces.
Comparing the stats on John Deere 5055E and New Holland Workmaster 50, one can quickly notice how similar both machines are.
John Deere vs New Holland Compact Tractors
John Deere 5310 vs New Holland 3630 Special Edition
5310 and 3630 Special Edition tractors feature many distinctions that set them apart.
John Deere 5310 and New Holland 3630 Special Edition both boast 55 horsepower engines for powerful yet flexible operation.
Both tractors feature comfortable operator’s cabs with adjustable seats and digital instruments; however, the John Deere 5310 may offer more space and comfort during extended workdays due to its larger cabin.
John Deere 5310s feature 9 forward and 3 reverse gears via their collar shift gearbox, while New Holland 3630 Special Editions provide 8 forward and 2 backward gears via constant mesh transmission for flexible controllability. Both options provide efficient performance.
The New Holland 3630 Special Edition boasts a 42 liter-per-minute pump compared to 20 for John Deere 5310, providing more effective attachment operations.
John Deere 5310 and New Holland 3630 Special Edition tractors are highly durable and versatile tractors ideal for small to mid-sized farms as well as a range of activities.
The former features a larger cabin and more transmission gears; while its counterpart offers a larger hydraulic pump. Selection will depend upon personal preferences, availability, pricing, and dealer support in the local area.
John Deere vs New Holland Round Baler
John Deere and New Holland both offer outstanding round balers, each boasting its own set of strengths and weaknesses.
J.D offers an assortment of round balers with various features and options, from variable chamber models to fixed chamber versions, that are known for their durable yet reliable construction, advanced technology capabilities, and automation features.
New Holland provides round balers that feature features such as bale density control, net wraps and wide pickups for efficient design. Their Roll-Belt technology can increase bale density while simultaneously decreasing hay loss.
Final decisions between John Deere and New Holland round balers depend on an individual’s needs and preferences, as well as factors like capacity, density, dealer support and local dealer presence. It is advisable to do research into specific models and features prior to making your selection.
John Deere vs new Holland Combine
New Holland recently invited the Prairie Agricultural Machinery Institute (PAMI) to conduct independent combine productivity comparison tests between Model Year 2015 New Holland CR9.90 Elevation and John Deere S690 combines.
PAMI has four decades of experience testing harvesting equipment around the world, with a specialization in Western Canadian crops and conditions. In September 2015, they conducted testing at PAMI’s Saskatchewan facility on wheat and canola crops to assess harvest productivity as well as fuel consumption efficiency.
- New Holland has a 4% better harvesting productivity in wheat and up to 10% in canola.
- The CR Elevation combine harvested 9% more grain per gallon of fuel and DEF than the Deere S690.
- There is an incredible difference of 13% gallons of fuel per acre in wheat and a 9% difference in canola. On a farm of 5,000 acres with 2,500 acres of wheat and canola, using the New Holland combine can result in savings of up to $18,000 CAD per year (or approximately $13,000 USD) – that’s an incredible $3.60 savings per acre!
John Deere vs New Holland Discbine
John Deere and New Holland offer discbines for harvesting hay and fodder with conditioning systems that collect them before forming windrows for drying and baling.
J.D discbines offer working widths ranging from 9 to 13 feet and feature flail or chevron conditioning systems for effortless performance and easy maintenance and repair. Reliable, efficient, and simple in design and operation – John Deere’s discbines make any task simpler!
New Holland discbine types range from 7.5 to 15 feet working widths with either steel or rubber conditioning systems, IntelliGuard cutterbar protection, and hydraulic roll pressure systems as the defining factors.
Compare John Deere vs New Holland discbines by cutting width, conditioning system, and local dealer assistance before selecting one brand over the other. Before making your choice, compare models and characteristics before making an informed decision.
John Deere vs New Holland Skid Steer
John Deere and New Holland skid steers have several distinctions that set them apart.
Both brands provide skid steers with different horsepower, operational capacity, and lift height options.
John Deere and New Holland skid steers are available with 49 to 110 horsepower depending on the model type, offering both vertical and radial lift paths.
John Deere and New Holland skid steers are comparable in operational capacity and lift height, though John Deere holds an edge with regard to breakout force.
Both manufacturers offer adjustable chairs with ergonomic controls and easily-read instrument panels, with John Deere skid steers offering air-conditioned operator stations and premium seats.
John Deere and New Holland both offer buckets, forks, and grapples for skid steers; J. D has more implements and attachments available than New Holland.
John Deere and New Holland both produce durable, effective skid steers designed for various applications. When purchasing one, consider your personal preferences, availability, pricing, local dealer support services, and price/feature comparison. Before making your choice.
John Deere vs New Holland which is better?
Comparing Warranties Between New Holland and John Deere There are two significant distinctions when it comes to warranties: John Deere Warranty Preview – Online or at the Dealer — Before making a significant investment, be sure to know if seals, hydraulic system coverage, and attachment coverage are included.
New Holland offers an online version of its warranty for compact tractors, while John Deere provides a standard warranty for their Boomer 35/40/45/50/55 compact tractors at no cost. Furthermore, their Boomer Guard6 Limited Warrant provides 6-years of coverage with two years of bumper-to-bumper coverage and four years of powertrain coverage
Unfortunately, we can’t tell you who has the best warranty. But that doesn’t make a difference in terms of service quality – it speaks volumes about each provider!
Parts And Maintenance
New Holland Parts are conveniently available near you, with one of the best parts distribution systems around. John Deere requires that you drive to a dealer which may be an hour or more away; with New Holland, just call us; we have parts, answers, and an experienced service team – many with 10+ years in service!
New Holland provides a local service team with parts supply and an unwavering commitment to the farming, Ag, and Construction communities in your area.
On the other hand, John Deere requires you to make a long drive to their nearest service center – taking time out of your day with more tasks on your list.
Strength VS. Weakness
Comparing New Holland and John Deere models, there won’t be much difference in terms of weight, power, or performance. The only real differences come down to personal preference and what you need from your machine for work.
Pricing can be an important factor, with New Holland models appearing more cost-effective than many similar John Deere models. While John Deere is a well-known brand, New Holland also has an established track record. Additionally, until recently, New Holland made skid steers for John Deere.
When considering the convenience of having local service instead of having to drive to a John Deere service center, John Deere may appear less desirable.
We started out thinking “Job Done,” but soon discovered there are obstacles in getting the job done. Waiting on parts or getting local service and parts can be an issue; another could be a higher cost of ownership from one brand versus the other.
It’s the little things that make a significant difference between New Holland and John Deere – investment-grade equipment can be pricey; with close capabilities, quality, and technology levels there really only one choice: New Holland.
In conclusion, John Deere vs. New Holland is a difficult question. Both brands offer reliable and effective equipment for a variety of applications. The choice depends on individual needs and preferences.
Compare John Deere with New Holland by pricing, features, availability, and local support. Before buying, compare models and features and test-drive equipment.
The best method to choose a brand is to assess your equipment demands, budget, and dealer’s reputation for customer service. Careful study and research can help you choose the right equipment.
- Kubota vs Mahindra Tractors
- Kubota vs. Kioti: Which is Better?
- Kubota vs. John Deere
- Kubota vs. Kioti: Which is Better?